Proposed changes to Cambridge School Committee rules were the focus of Tuesday, Nov. 17’s committee meeting, with the most significant being the addition of regular meeting time for participation from educators in the district’s largest labor union.
The proposed changes grew out of work from the Governance Subcommittee, which has been reviewing rules and regulations since February.
Several of the proposed changes are semantic tweaks to grammar and phrasing. For example, one proposed change substitutes the word “chair” for “mayor,” bringing the document in line with an updated city charter that allows the committee to elect its own chair instead of automatically assigning the role to the mayor.
But the most controversial of the proposed changes designates two meetings per year that would include presentations from members of the district’s largest labor union, the Cambridge Education Association. The idea is modeled partly on Arlington School Committee’s allowance of presentations from educators at meetings, according to Mayor Sumbul Siddiqui.
Some committee members and public commenters said they believe the change is sufficient, while others said it was not enough representation for educators.
How and when educators from the CEA, which represents over 1,500 district staff members, can participate in meetings was a key issue of the School Committee election last year, when several candidates ran with ideas for increasing educator participation. Several members have suggested a nonvoting seat for the union, which would allow a CEA representative to participate directly at meetings without the power to cast votes. A motion to do so was deferred to subcommittee in February.
Sarah Rosenberg, the union’s vice president of community relations, said during public comment that while “a designated agenda space for the CEA is a real acknowledgement,” educators should have a nonvoting seat, similar to how students are represented on the committee.
“Our educators do not want to borrow your stage time,” Jess Goetz, a Cambridge public schools parent, said during public comment.
Committee Member Luisa de Paula Santos also advocated for a nonvoting union seat, saying educators should have equal representation to administrators. Santos referenced the superintendent, who presents at every meeting and often invites other administrators to committee discussions.
Member Arjun Jaikumar suggested a revision to the language that would name the two presentations per year as a minimum, and the committee debated whether the revision would have any real impact.
Outside of committee meetings, the district has joint labor-management working groups where administrators collaborate with the union on specific issues.
Are posters allowed?
One potential revision opposed by most committee members at Tuesday’s meeting would prohibit signs, posters and placards from entering the meeting room, a change inspired by City Council rules.
Jaikumar called it a “restriction on speech,” as did Santos.
However, Committee Chair David Weinstein referenced a protest in June during which union members circled the committee’s table and delivered postcards, ignoring Weinstein’s objections. Weinstein suggested a designated avenue through which messages from the public should be collected.
Several of the other revisions to the rules deal with the power of the committee chair. Under current rules, only the chair can independently call meetings and set agendas. Otherwise, a two-thirds majority is required.
Proposed revisions simply clarify this rule. But some committee members expressed desire for guardrails that would limit the chair’s power. Jaikumar acknowledged that, while it was not the intention of the revision, the new language could have the potential to “delegate to the chair unilaterally the authority to cancel meetings or potentially cancel every meeting.”
Another proposed change would allow the school committee chair and mayor to collaborate on agendas for joint meetings between the committee and city council. Member Richard Harding said collaboration would have been useful during conversations earlier this year. For example, decisions around the vacant 158 Spring Street building fell under the jurisdiction of the School Committee, while the fate of its neighboring green space, Ahern Field, was the city’s responsibility.
The rules of public comment are also on the revision table, with a draft that would give permission for people to sign up as public commenters immediately before a meeting. Early this year, the committee discussed expanding the speaking limit for public commenters from the allotted three minutes, but that change was not discussed at Tuesday’s meeting.
Other proposed revisions would remove fixed office hours with committee members and would double the threshold needed for committee approval of service contracts.
No votes were taken at Tuesday’s meeting. The committee will vote item by item on proposed rule changes at its next meeting on Tuesday, Dec. 1.


