Let’s assume Somerville’s accessory dwelling unit proposal is meant to increase Somerville’s stock of affordable housing, giving the city another tool along with Affordable Homes Act and the current zoning ordinance. In fact, the Planning Department ADU proposal undermines this goal.
Instead of increasing the number of affordable dwelling units, the proposed Planning Department ADU proposal creates an incentive for developers to buy up lots in lower income neighborhoods that are able to accommodate a Backyard Cottage, split them into separate lots, and build a larger number of condominium dwelling units than permitted on the pre-existing single lot – and sell them at the high-priced end of the market. That is happening in Cambridge with a backlash from the unintended consequences of its loosened zoning restrictions and few affordable units.
In particular, the ill-conceived ADU proposal
- allows lot area available for affordable ADUs to be split and used for expensive, unaffordable large units,
- does not require a percentage of the new Accessory Dwelling Units to be affordable,
- is in violation of the state’s Affordable Homes Act.
Some speculate that just increasing low-rise housing stock will improve affordability through market forces of supply and demand. That is not how it works in an already exceptionally dense city, as our Senator Pat Jehlen has pointed out. And Somerville does not have the luxury of testing out that theory, given the telling example that Cambridge is now reconsidering. Of course, high prices do lead to more tax revenue, but solving Somerville’s short-term financial issues should not be the goal of promoting ADUs.
Instead, Somerville needs the ADU zoning to require a minimum number of permanently affordable units on ADU eligible lots. For example, 20% of the dwelling units from five and above rounded to the nearest whole number need to be affordable. Thus, a lot with five dwelling units would have at least one be affordable; a lot with eight dwelling units would have two be affordable.
Somerville’s Backyard Cottage under current zoning fits the Affordable Homes Act definition of an ADU. But lot splitting needs to be prohibited to curtail luxury housing, and ADU zoning needs to meet the Affordable Homes Act Gross Floor Area limit of 900 sq. ft.
New ADUs need to be all-electric. Electrifying buildings to replace oil and natural gas will mitigate greenhouse gas emissions, an additional important Somerville goal. Buildings produce 65% of Somerville’s greenhouse gas emissions, as recognized by SomerVision 2040 and Somerville’s Climate Forward Plan, which seek by 2040 to reduce them by 80% (pp. 18-20) from the 2014 level. Therefore, newly constructed ADUs need to be all electric.
Keeping Somerville green and livable. Greening Somerville to reduce adverse health impacts from excessive temperature and to mitigate air pollution are also Somerville’s goals. Density also adversely affects privacy and open spaces, so Somerville needs to keep setbacks and manage building siting to keep existing larger trees and provide for sufficient tree planting space, air flow and view sheds. A tree canopy can lower the temperature by as much as 10 degrees Fahrenheit in what would otherwise be a high temperature neighborhood. Housing affordability and lowering neighborhood temperatures with urban trees are compatible partners that should be part of any ADU policy. Somerville has been recognized as a Tree City USA by the Arbor Day Foundation. Let’s not lose that accolade. Do not plant affordable ADUs at the expense of trees and livability. Plan, plant and preserve them together.
So, back to the Planning Department’s drawing board!
Woll is a member of Davis Square Village and Davis Square Neighborhood Council



Let me guess, Ed owns his own home, and that should tell us what the “unintended consequences” are from the article he linked to.
That’s why he’s simultaneously arguing against low-rise development and saying that density is a bad thing. Explicitly – that Somerville is bad as it is, that it needs stricter setback requirements so that it looks more suburban.
Cambridge isn’t exactly a cautionary tale here. The same people that are the “backlash” now were largely the same people that opposed the ordinance before it passed, and were largely the same people that opposed the AHO in the past as well. These are largely the same people that oppose any given project in the city, regardless of what ordinance it was able to be built under. This doesn’t represent any meaningful shift in public opinion that the article you link to insinuates, upzoning is still very popular here. You call it “unintended consequences”, but I’d argue that what we’re seeing through the MFHO is exactly what was intended by the ordinance: more housing.
Low rise development with affordable housing should be a goal but the Cambridge ordinance is not written to assure achievement of the affordable part of the goal but is being criticized for allowing it to be used to build high end market rate units. The same can be said for the proposed Somerville ordinance.
NIMBYs criticize every proposal to address the housing crisis while offering no solutions of their own. Woll’s critique is no exception:
He starts with a straw man: treating ADUs as an affordable-housing program, then faulting them for not being one.
He treats rising rents as proof that adding housing doesn’t work, without asking how much higher rents would have risen without it. Peer-reviewed research finds that new market-rate buildings lower nearby rents by 5–7%.
The Jehlen figure of “1,775 homes” is disputed.
His own proposal, a 20% affordability mandate starting at five units, gives builders a reason to stop at four.
He exaggerates. Cambridge is making modest adjustments to setbacks and open-space requirements, not retreating from rezoning.
The “backlash” he cites is the same people repeating the same objections they raised before reform.
He claims the policy “violates the Affordable Homes Act” without identifying which provision it violates or how.
This is another flimsy argument for letting existing homeowners keep others from having homes.
Contrary to the impressions provided by two commenters, I live in a 6-unit, 3-story building on a street where very few lots, if any, have open lot area sufficient for a backyard cottage or additional dwellings. In other words, it is not a NIMBY street. The point the commenters elide over is that an ADU program should create affordable housing and this one does not. The incentives are to build market rate housing. That would increase Somerville property tax revenue but not the number of affordable units. If this Planning Department proposal was intended to comply with the Affordable Housing Act, it does not do that either – the maximum gross floor area for an ADU under that act is the smaller of 900 sq ft or half the GFA of the principal building. As for affordability, under current zoning, you can put 4 marker rate dwelling units on a lot. Starting with a threshold of five, with one being affordable, is more than the Planning Department proposal does, which has no affordable unit threshold. Ed Woll
Rising rents after 1,775 new homes doesn’t prove supply failed. It suggests those homes weren’t enough to meet the region’s much larger shortage.
Woll’s plan won’t create deed-restricted affordable housing. But neither will his alternative, which would produce little housing at all. A 20% affordability mandate starting at five units encourages builders to stop at four. Add a 900-square-foot cap, a lot-split ban, full setbacks, and tree protections, and few lots remain buildable.
Woll’s proposals would preserve the status quo, not address the housing crisis. Once again, opponents of development offer restrictions instead of solutions. They have their homes. Renters are left paying the price.