A safe landing at Logan after a bird-plane clash shows progress made since 62 deaths in 1960
You may have read that on Oct. 5, a Delta flight from Boston to Fort Lauderdale, Florida, hit some birds on takeoff and was forced to return to Logan. No passengers were hurt, and the plane landed normally and taxied back to the gate. Mechanics inspected the plane and the flight was rescheduled for 3 p.m. that same day.
Because airports today know how to manage bird populations, events such as this are extremely rare; when they do occur, the risk is minimized because the number of birds near airports is low and aircraft are built to withstand bird impacts or ingestion into their engines.
But 62 years ago, on Oct. 4, 1960, the most deadly bird air strike in U.S. history occurred right here at Logan Airport. A flock of approximately 20,000 starlings flew in front of an Eastern Airlines Lockheed L-188 Electra turbo-prop airplane within seconds of takeoff. Dozens of the starlings were ingested into three of the four engines as the plane took off from Runway 9. Two engines lost power. A third flamed out. Flight 375 rolled over and crashed into Winthrop Bay. Sixty-two of the 72 people on board died.
“My friends were all on the beach at the base of Woodside Park that late afternoon. We stood still and watched the big Electra drop out of the sky, right in front of us. It made a huge steam splash as it hit very close to the No. 2 red buoy of the Cottage Park Club. We ran out on the flats to help,” one eyewitness said.
The survivors were all in the airplane’s rear section, which broke off from the rest of the fuselage. The seats and the seat belts broke, too, allowing these 10 people – nine with serious injuries – to surface and be rescued by boats. The rest of the plane was destroyed and broke apart on impact. More people probably would have survived the crash if it were not for the poorly designed seats, which detached from the airplane floor mounts and tipped in the bay to float upside down, causing the strapped-in occupants to drown. According to The Boston Globe, “only two seats in the entire plane remained attached to the floor. All the rest were ripped away.”
The Civil Aeronautics Board conducted a review of the incident and concluded:
A few seconds after becoming airborne, the aircraft struck a flock of starlings. A number of these birds were ingested in engines Nos. 1, 2 and 4. Engine No. 1 was shut down and its propeller was feathered [the pilot turned the fan blades to eliminate drag]. Nos. 2 and 4 experienced a substantial momentary loss of power. This abrupt and intermittent loss and recovery of power resulted in the aircraft yawing to the left and decelerating to the stall speed … the left wing dropped, the nose pitched up and the aircraft rolled left into a spin and fell almost vertically into the water.
After the crash, investigators found the remains of approximately 75 starlings scattered on the left side of Runway 9. They also found starling remains and feathers in three engines of the plane. Investigators later conducted tests, which involved firing living starlings into the spinning blades of Electra engines; the investigators ascertained that indeed starlings could have caused the plane to crash:
Starlings were introduced into an operating engine in varying number and sequences … The tests demonstrated that substantial power interruptions and emissions of flame from the tailpipe would occur when starlings were ingested … Subsequently another test program was incorporated … Various numbers of starlings were ingested into the engine at different power settings and [wind] tunnel speeds.
The Civil Aeronautics Board also used a flight simulator to recreate what occurred during the brief flight. More than 60 pilots tried to fly and land the plane under these conditions. All failed.
The good news is that officials learned a great deal from this accident, and U.S. airports today have wildlife hazard management programs in place to ensure that incidents like this do not occur again. Part of that work is to reduce flocks of birds such as starlings near airports by having airport wildlife management crews remove food and water sources, as well as nesting sites. Also because of this accident, regulators developed minimum ingestion standards for propellor planes and later for modern jet airplanes. Today, rather than using living birds, engineers test jet engines using gelatin blocks that mimic bird density.
Bird strikes have been occurring as long as there have been airplanes. In 1905, Orville Wright hit a red-winged blackbird while flying above a Dayton, Ohio cornfield. In 2019 there were about 17,228 wildlife strikes, 97.5 percent of which were birds, at 753 U.S. airports. If my calculations are correct, this means there were on average about 47 bird strikes per day. Most of these incidents were not serious, of course. In 2012, a plane carrying Joseph Biden struck some birds near Santa Barbara, California. The passengers onboard, including Biden, were not even aware anything had happened.
Have you taken photos of our urban wild things? Send your images to Cambridge Day, and we may use them as part of a future feature. Include the photographer’s name and the general location where the photo was taken.
Jeanine Farley is an educational writer who has lived in the Boston area for more than 30 years. She enjoys taking photos of our urban wild things.