Micromobility devices are increasingly common on city streets, and laws havenโ€™t kept up with their proliferation.

The lack of public outreach around pending state laws for e-bikes and scooters came in for criticism from Cambridge city councillors at their Monday meeting, with city staff assuring that people will get their chance to weigh in.

Elected officials are โ€œhearing every day practically about some e-bike or an e-scooter or how this person cannot get around the city,โ€ said councillor Patty Nolan, author of a Sept. 8 order drawing Mondayโ€™s city response.ย 

Officials and staff agree it is confusing what control the city has on the devices, which rangeย  from skateboards to wheelchairs, and where city laws may come into play, especially when some of the devices arenโ€™t even acknowledged by state law as existing.

The stateโ€™s new Special Commission on Micromobility met five times starting in April and held its final official meeting Monday. It expects to issue a report in January, said transportation commissioner Brooke McKenna in briefing councillors and responding to Nolansโ€™s order. โ€œIt would be at that point that we would probably want to have a committee hearing, if that was the will of the council, and start to get the word out on what the recommendations were,โ€ McKenna said.

The Transportation Committee is run by councillor Cathie Zusy, who won reelection Tuesday. But itโ€™s not certain the next mayor will keep her in that role.ย 

Zusy said she met with McKenna a month ago to consider a hearing and opted to hold off until after the commission released its report.

Though the city sent recommendations and an extensive list of questions to the commission, Nolan believed her order was intended to spark public comment at the start of that process. โ€œAll of us wanted it on the table before the recommendations came out,โ€ Nolan said Monday. โ€œThe intent was that we let the community know that now is the time to actually send your comments into the micromobility commission before they have their final meeting.โ€

The order left room for interpretation, Nolan acknowledged: Its text asked staff to โ€œinform the community of the work ofโ€ the commission and when the recommendations coming from the state commission will be available.

The state commissionโ€™s meetings didnโ€™t have public comment periods, McKenna said.

With the state in control and no guarantee that Cambridgeโ€™s recommendations would be taken up quickly or at all, the city may yet have to run some process of its own, McKenna said. โ€œAcross the board, every user group wants more clarity on these issues,โ€ she said.

That answer didnโ€™t satisfy councillor Ayesha Wilson, who said she was unaware of the work of the state commission until McKennaโ€™s report and suggested Cambridge could have done something to make up for โ€œthe state’s shortcoming with their process.โ€

The state commissionโ€™s tasks are to update and clarify state laws about micromobility devices while finding ways to expand their use, reducing short car trips and improving first- and last-mile connections to transit. The work is part of statewide goals to cut emissions, improve mobility and strengthen the economy.

Residents who spoke at the meeting, though, said they wanted fewer micromobility devices on public paths and are frustrated with how people use e-bikes and scooters: โ€œwilly-nilly all over the place,โ€ resident James Williamson said. โ€œItโ€™s just crazy, itโ€™s scary, itโ€™s dangerous.โ€

Scooters and e-bike riders often zip through crowded areas and many, especially delivery workers for DoorDash and Uber Eats, donโ€™t follow traffic rules or keep safe speeds, Williamson said. Fellow commenter Heather Hoffman mentioned micromobility devices โ€œgoing at high speed the wrong way down the bike lanes.โ€

Both called the issue urgent.


Feature image by pony via Unsplash.

A stronger

Please consider making a financial contribution to maintain, expand and improve Cambridge Day.

We are now a 501(c)3 nonprofit and all donations are tax deductible.

Please consider a recurring contribution.

Join the Conversation

4 Comments

  1. I think people making claims about the horrible behavior of people using scooters and e-scooters should sit down with a video camera and record all the behavior, problematic and otherwise, so that we can all see what they think the problem is. Otherwise, I think they only see/remember the bad cases.

    I have biked to work in Kendall, usually collecting video, for the last 10 years, every working day. I am usually using some sort of bicycle infrastructure in Cambridge, either sharrow, cycle track, lane, or protected lane. I see (and record) people using various devices. Most people using e-things are using them responsibly, and if we simply extended existing e-bike laws to include them, then we already have a good set of laws — 20mph assist limit, slow+yielding on sidewalks, and banned from sidewalks in business districts.

    The ban on e-bikes on sidewalks should be removed, “slow and yielding” does the job, and the current ban disconnects the bike network in places.

  2. Couldn’t disagree more with dr2chase comments.
    I’m going to sit down with a video camera & record bike & scooter infractions? Seriously? As a pedestrian, senior & bike owner who has not owned a car in Cambridge since 1996, I have found the delivery E-bikes, motorized scooters & blue bike drivers without helmets, racing thru Yield & Stop signs, driving on sidewalks at far too high a speed while simultaneously looking down at their phones & paying little attention. As a result of numerous near misses, aggressive “on your left” yahoos, flagrant disregard for the rules of the road, I rarely use my bike anymore since I and many other seniors feel we’ve been pushed or forced off. I have also noticed, that now that I’m much more of a ‘pedestrian,’ even that has become challenging or dangerous since scooter people & Blue bike tourists seem frequently oblivious to basic rules & consideration. It’s kinda nuts out there & both the city & riders need to do more to calm things down.

  3. dr2chase

    The only reason you want e-bikes on the sidewalk is so they aren’t in your precious bike lane. The only form of transport I haven’t seen on the streets is a pogo stick. Beyond ridiculous!

Leave a comment