โ€œZiโ€

Rating: 2.5 out of 4.

In โ€œZi,โ€ video essayist turned filmmaker Kogonada ( โ€œAfter Yangโ€) returns to his roots, pivoting from the flashy Hollywood misfire โ€œA Big Bold Beautiful Journeyโ€ (2025) to a film so low budget it feels handmade. Michelle Mao (โ€œBridgertonโ€) plays Zi Wong, a concert violinist plagued with hallucinatory visions from her life โ€” many of which have yet to occur. While sobbing on the streets of Hong Kong, Zi meets Elle (Haley Lu Richardson, โ€œSupport the Girlsโ€), a free-spirited American expat who happens to feature in several of Ziโ€™s premonitions. Elle befriends Zi then takes her to see a neurologist (and Elleโ€™s ex-fiancรฉ) Min (Jin Ha, โ€œPachinkoโ€). The trio embarks on a bleary, bittersweet all-night tour of Hong Kongโ€™s neon-lit alleys.

Far from the technicolor excess of โ€œJourney,โ€ โ€œZiโ€ is at times almost unbearably intimate, resembling a home movie as much as a film from a well-known director. Kogonada shot the movie with a handheld 16mm camera, deliberately leaving in lens flares and other defects in the medium. While seemingly not improvised, the film has a shaggy, impressionistic feel, expressing its story through images and moods as much as through conventional plotting. Kogonada has a street photographerโ€™s eye, capturing Hong Kong in gorgeous candid images. Even when we canโ€™t quite get a bead on the nature of Ziโ€™s problems, we understand what sheโ€™s feeling through the sheer emotion of the images.

Hong Kong features prominently in “Zi.” Credit: Divergent PR

The spell breaks to a degree when the characters open their mouths. While Mao is quite moving while expressing her characterโ€™s anxiety, Richardson and Ha are saddled with clunky dialogue, overexplaining their relationship to the audience rather than allowing us to fill in the gaps. Those looking for a cohesive narrative might find themselves frustrated by the filmโ€™s deliberate opacity.

Still, in a film like โ€œZi,โ€ these ragged edges may be features rather than bugs. By retreating from Hollywood, Kogonada essentially resets his career, creating something that frequently feels more like a first film than his actual debut, โ€œColumbusโ€ (2017). His scope will likely again expand, but letโ€™s hope he retains โ€œZiโ€โ€™s sense of experimentation. Like his characters, Kogonada is at his best when he allows himself to get lost in the alleys. โ€” Oscar Goff

Playing at Brattle Theatre from Nov. 20 to Nov. 24

โ€œEbenezerโ€

Rating: 2 out of 4.
Tramell Tillman plays Ghost of Christmas Present and Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge in “Ebenezer.” Credit: Paramount Pictures

Do we need another cinematic version of Dickensโ€™ timeless great, โ€œA Christmas Carolโ€? The answer is a qualified โ€œno,โ€ as this redemption vehicle for Johnny Depp gets mired in the heavy-handed moodiness and unnecessary jump scares of director Ti West. The art-house horror darling (โ€œ Xโ€ (2022) and โ€œ MaXXXineโ€ (2024)) was rewarded for his notoriety with a bigger canvas and budget, but misses the message of this story.

To be clear, Deppโ€™s not bad in a role performed by the likes of Alastair Sim, Albert Finney, Michael Caine, Patrick Stewart, Mr. Magoo and Bill Murray, all of whom knocked it out of the park. The issue is West focuses so much on Scrooge he loses sight of the social ills Dickens brought his lens to: poverty, economic inequality, squalid living conditions, limited human services and the evils of child labor. Westโ€™s sensibilities for โ€™70s porn, sudden death from unexpected sources and all things Mia Goth are spot on, but Dickensโ€™ horrors came from interior torment, not visual effects. The film hangs on Depp โ€” nearly unrecognizable under gobs of latex and special effects โ€” who acts his prosthetic proboscis off, but heโ€™ll hardly be remembered for the take.

Westโ€™s setup from Nathaniel Halpernโ€™s script buries the socioeconomic and medical plight of Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint) and Tiny Tim (Freddie Lee-Grey) until midway through. Up to that point, Scrooge is repugnant primarily in countenance, his miserly and demanding demeanor lacking consequences. Even the ghosts of Scroogeโ€™s late, like-minded partner, Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), and of Christmas Past, Present and Future (To Come) all take a while getting around to Scroogeโ€™s miscues.

The Past segment (ghost played by Andrea Riseborough) does create sympathy, as we the young Scrooge (Arthur Conti) fall in love with a woman played by Ellie Bamber and confront street violence and poverty. But as the film progresses it becomes less emotively rooted and at times feels performative. The makeup and sets are fantastic, and West can conjure a nasty mood, but the longer he dwells on the ghosts, the less we feel the human misery that made Dickensโ€™ story so unsettling in the first place. โ€” Tom Meek

Playing at Apple Cinemas Cambridge and AMC Assembly Row 12

A stronger

Please consider making a financial contribution to maintain, expand and improve Cambridge Day.

We are now a 501(c)(3) nonprofit and all donations are tax deductible.

Please consider a recurring contribution.

Leave a comment