City failed to protect trees in Danehy Park
The visit to Danehy Park came in mid-August, after reading a description from city councillor Quinton Zondervan: “The conditions were shockingly hot and dry. All the ground is brown, all the grass is dead … one of the stands of trees in particular is in serious trouble.” Ruth Loetterle and I went; we categorized 108 trees to be in a range from “poor” to “dead.” Of them, 87 were mature and classified as “significant trees” by city ordinance – which values the “dead” trees at about $120,000.
The park’s irrigation system had failed, and repairs did not start until Aug. 8. Backup irrigation for the 50-acre park was next to impossible with only three fire hydrants and without help from the fire department.
To be sure, our count of “dead” trees can rightfully be questioned. What cannot be questioned is that a drought started in May and later became categorized as “extreme,” and city management didn’t fix the irrigation until August. The actual damage won’t be known until “leaf out” in the spring, but when a mature tree has no leaves in August it’s absolutely in “poor” condition. Worse, now that the irrigation has been on for a month, some trees have put out new leaves for the fall instead of the spring. This can’t be good.
Why should you care?
The importance of trees for public health, especially in heat waves, was recognized when the city created its “tree task force” in 2018, updated the tree ordinance in 2021 and passed a council order in September declaring that trees are “essential infrastructure.”
Danehy Park is very important for healthy youth and family activities, with its many sports fields, water playground, public restrooms and cookout area. It’s between the affordable housing of the Rindge Towers and the hundreds of affordable units across from the park’s Sherman Street entrance. The park’s trees supply not only shade in the age of multiple heat waves and extended droughts, but emotional support to adults and children trying to relax in the park.
Why the slow response?
City management is not organized to respond to a drought emergency. Park management is distributed across multiple departments and divisions of departments, and those then must navigate various other departments, such as purchasing and legal. Human Services has oversight of Danehy Park, the Fresh Pond Golf Course and others; the Water Department has Fresh Pond Reservation; the Conservation Commission has community gardens; the Department of Public Works overlaps park responsibilities between its Parks Division and Urban Forestry Division. The Community Development Department does park designs. This is baroque and broken.
City management failed to train city staff, contractors and vendors on the public health importance or even the monetary value of trees – the time it took to repair the irrigation system suggests this. After many years and countless hours of climate change planning, task forces and committees, it’s clear that city management had no contingency plans for this inevitable drought and inevitable equipment failures.
Our new city manager should reorganize existing staff into an independent Parks & Trees Department with a mission statement implementing the existing tree master plan and, for parks, balancing priorities of green open space with healthy trees and recreation facilities to maximize Public Health.
Charles Teague has been advocating for preserving the tree canopy and Linear Park since 2016. Ruth Loetterle, categorized the trees using Teague’s measurements, was appointed by the City Manager’s Office to the Committee on Public Planting and has recently retired from a 35-year career with a local landscape architectural firm. She holds a Bachelor of Science in botany and a Master of Landscape Architecture, and serves on the board of Grow Native Massachusetts.
“and city management didn’t fix the irrigation until August”
So typical of the city. We spend a lot of money for an arborist and his crew. How could they let this happen. I’ll tell you why. He is incompetent. Took down a perfectly healthy tree, according to our landscaping people, and refused to cut a small branch hanging over our electric line.
So many city employees are good and do their job. Others employees are just there to fill slots and can’t wait for retirement and the incredible health benefits that are going to bankrupt this city.
This city keeps adding more and more unneeded
positions. It is a bloated bureaucracy. Just look at what the new City Manager is proposing with just
two “new” positions.
All this city knows is how to spend money needlessly. But, when it comes to people doing their jobs e.g. making sure that Danehy Park is properly looked after, they either do not care or
are incompetent.
My question is whether the DPW watered the Fresh Pond golf course during this heavy, hot, dry summer. VERY offensive for city DPW & by extension the council to be reaching out to resident volunteers to water street trees–garden hoses don’t reach most of them anyway– when the annual city budget developed by the council does not fund the staff or the equipment to water trees and care for them effectively. Instead of paying to produce and deliver that 4-color brochure about the annual budget to residents, the Water Dept.’s annual brochure, & the annual RE tax brochure, for starters, post the info online and in all libraries and schools while putting the money for them henceforth into funding and equipping professional, effective year-round care for the city’s tree canopy. Think about Cambridge Trees and City Councillors, voters, especially running up to the Nov. 7, 2023 Council election.
Ms. McClellan,
Unfortunately, on November 7, 2023, most, if not
all, of the city councilors will be elected. They will continue to talk a good story, but in reality they just won’t care about getting important things done.
Blame it on the city’s Plan E government structure. Blame it on the very low turnout in the municipal election, blame it on the fact that the members prefer to rant and rave about unimportant things, blame it on a host of other things, but the fact of the matter is that they just don’t care.
City Councilors, metaphorically… fix the damn potholes.
Thank you Anita. I’m similarly baffled that the city prioritized keeping the golf course bright green during a draught, while residents were asked to hose down the trees in their neighborhoods. If the golfers can have a dedicated water supply, can’t the more public parks and neighborhood trees? What a disappointment.